We dive into the first part of Jesus' Bread of Life Discourse in Jn. 6:22-35. We compared and contrasted the traditional teaching on this passage from those who do not rightly-divide the Scriptures with a non-traditional interpretation that does.
John 6:22-35: A NON-TRADITIONAL Interpretation
The traditional interpretation of John 6 is based the preconceived notion that the Gospel of John is the handbook of personal evangelism for individual salvation in the Dispensation of Grace. I used to say this interpretation reads Paul into the context, but that is not really true. It is far worse that. It reads Martin Luther into the context. But to do this is to wrongly divide the Scriptures. It discards the fact that Jesus Christ came AT THAT TIME to bring about Israel's NATIONAL salvation, confirming and fulfilling God's promises to the Nation of Israel's fathers (Rom. 15:8). John 6 should instead be read in the far context of the Old Testament, especially the Exodus Account, and the near context of the three principles Jesus declared in John 5.
So, what might an interpretation based on rightly-dividing the Word of God look like? Let's take a shot at it with a paraphrase of this passage, albeit a loose paraphrase:
Introduction: Jn. 6:1-21: Through the two signs in Jn. 6--the Feeding of the 5,000 and the Walking on the Water—John gives us the basic theme of the rest of the chapter. In the sign of the Feeding of the 5,000 he introduces the BREAD theme (Jn. 6:7-11), and in the sign of the Walking on the Water He introduces the I AM ___ theme (Jn. 6:20). And if you put them together, you have I AM the Bread of Life (Jn. 6:35, 41, 48, 51).
Setting: Jn. 6:22-24: The crowd witnessed Jesus' signs of healing on the west side of the Sea of Galilee and participated in His feeding of the 5,000 on the east side. The next morning, Jesus' disciples are gone, and Jesus didn't go with them. Jesus has mysteriously disappeared. So, the crowds actively, busily, even frantically look for Him over land and over sea (Jn. 6:22‑25). But He's not there. They conclude that they need to continue their fervent search for Jesus on the other side of the sea. So, they hop into boats and row as hard and fast as they can. Perhaps they are becoming suspicious that another supernatural event had occurred during the night. While they weren't present to see Jesus walking on the water, they might wonder how else could He get across the sea without a boat?
The Crowd: Jn. 6:25: Finally and perhaps out of breath, the crowd finds Him and ask: Rabbi (Master—Jn. 1:38), when did you get here. Perhaps they were trying to ascertain whether He had time to get Capernaum on foot by walking around the north side of the sea.
Jesus: Jn. 6:26-27: Jesus ignores their question. Instead, He tells them they are focusing on the wrong things and asking the wrong questions. The question they should be asking is what, exactly, are we laboriously working/seeking after? Jesus breaks it down the options for them:
- First, He points out that they saw the signs, but they didn't receive the One to whom the signs pointed—God's Sent One, the Lord Jesus Christ. All the sign of the Feeding of the 5,00 pointed them to was their own empty and filled stomachs.
- Therefore, they should not “work” strenuously seeking after the food that perishes (like the manna of old—Ex. 16:20‑21) and that sustains physical life only temporarily (like yesterday's meal and the manna of old--Num. 26:65). Rather, they should “work” strenuously seeking after the food that Jesus can give as the Son of Man. For He is the only One who has God's seal of approval and all authority to bring believing Israel into everlasting life.
The Crowd: Jn. 6:28: But the crowd wasn't listening. They were not interested in eternal life and individual salvation. They were interested in filling their bellies with the food that perishes. Recognizing that Jesus is not going to feed them again, they persist in their endeavor by saying in effect: Ok, Jesus, if you won't feed us again now, tell us how to do it ourselves. We will do the works of God. It must be noted that the only works of God in context are the works that Jesus has been doing, the healings and the feeding signs. The crowd explicitly equates Jesus' production of a sign with His work in Jn. 6:30. This is ominously reminiscent of Israel's fatal words at Sinai: We will do all that you say (Ex. 1:8)! We don't need to rely on the LORD. We will do it ourselves. Then they went under the Mosaic Law system according to the flesh and spent the next 1500 years under the Curses of the Law in the Courses of Punishment.
No doubt, they reasoned that if regular people like Moses and Jesus can do the works of God, why can't they! Again, this is ominously reminiscent of times when the Israelites rebelled against Moses. Aaron and Miriam, for instance, rebelled against Moses saying: Has the LORD indeed spoken only by Moses? Has He not spoken by us also! And the LORD brought judgment down upon them (Num. 12:1-15). Not long after that, Korah and a large group of ruling Israelites likewise rebelled against Moses saying: You take too much upon you, seeing all the congregation is holy, every one of them, wherefore, then lift yourselves above the congregation of the LORD? Once again, God's judgment fell, and the earth swallowed up Korah with hundreds of his companions (Num. 16:1-35).
Jesus: Jn. 6:29: Jesus goes on to explain that they are focusing on the wrong things. Instead of desiring to do the works/signs that God is doing through Me, they should be focusing on the Work that God is doing right now, AT THIS TIME, in My earthly ministry! The work that God is now doing is the sending and giving of His Son (Jn. 6:29b, 32b) to whom He is giving, leading and drawing those who belong to Him so that they receive, believe and follow Him into life (Jn. 6:37, 44).
The Crowd: Jn. 6:30-31: The crowd is still not listening. They are still focused on getting the bread that perishes to fill their empty stomachs. They persist in their endeavor: Well, if Jesus isn't going to give us the food that perishes, and He won't tell us how to do it ourselves, then maybe we can tempt Him into doing it. So, they say, “Show us a sign, do a work, so that we might believe!” This even though they have already seen many signs of healing and the massive sign of the Feeding of the 5,000 yet remain in unbelief!! If You are greater than Moses give us a sign that goes beyond what he did. Moses gave our fathers manna to eat for 40 years! Why don't you one-up Moses and feed us with physical bread from Heaven for 40+ years. Then, indeed, we will believe!!!
Jesus: Jn. 6:32-33: But the crowd betrays its ignorance and unbelief in God, the Scriptures and Moses (Jn. 5:37-47). They see the manna and Moses, but they don't see the LORD and don't know the Scriptures (Neh. 9:15; Ps. 78:24‑25; 105:40). Jesus shows their error: Moses didn't give them manna: GOD GAVE THEM MANNA FROM HEAVEN! They betray that they don't really believe in God, the Scriptures or Moses. Therefore, they will reject Christ in unbelief because they reject the witness of Moses and the Scriptures, and don't recognize the Father in the Son (Jn. 5:37-47).
But now, the Father is working through the earthly ministry of Jesus Christ to give Israel the TRUE Bread from Heaven. The manna/bread from Heaven of their ancient history was just the type, the shadow. Now God was working to give them the antitype and the substance. The antitype and substance isn't a thing like physical bread. It is a HE, a PERSON, the Lord Jesus Christ. The Work of God is God sending His Son to give life to the world, which in God's Prophetic Program with the Nation of Israel, begins with Israel and through Israel, the world.
The Crowd: Jn. 6:34: The crowd is still pursuing the bread that perishes in unbelief (Jn. 6:36). Give us this bread forevermore—ie., not just today, not just for the next 40+ years but forever!
Jesus: Jn. 6:35: The crowd is still not listening. They are willfully stopping their ears. They are still seeking the bread that is a thing even though Jesus just told them it is not a thing. It is a PERSON! It is Himself!! So, He tries to break through the wall of unbelief by clearly and definitively proclaiming: I AM the Bread of Life—He who. It is as though Jesus raises His eyes above the crowd and looks beyond those standing before Him. There, out at the edge of the horizon, He sees another community of people, a community of believers, a community made up of He Who have come and believed on Him and will, therefore, never hunger or thirst again.