One of the highlights from yesterday's message came from answering the question: Who Is John the Baptist? This is an important question because the Vain Religious System (VRS) in Jesus' day insisted that Elijah needed to come before the Messiah came. John insisted that he was not Elijah (Jn. 1:21). Therefore, according to the counter-doctrine of the VRS, if John was not Elijah, then the messenger of Mal. 3, the forerunner of the Messiah, had not come either. And, if the forerunner of the Messiah had not come, then the Messiah could not come either. By conflating the 1st and 2nd Comings of Christ and by conflating the two messengers of Malachi 3 and 4, the VRS could not only do away with the necessity of John the Baptist's ministry but with the necessity of Christ's earthly ministry at His 1st Coming as well.
Let's take a closer look at the argument. In Mal. 3:1 the LORD said: Behold, I will send My messenger, and he shall prepare the way before Me. Then in Mal. 4:5 He said: Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful Day of the Lord. The VRS said that Elijah, in the latter reference, was the same person as the messenger in the former reference. This allowed them to do away with the possibility of two messengers, who would come before two separate Comings of the Lord. According to Mal. 4:5, Elijah will come before the dreadful and terrible Day of the Lord. This is a reference to the end times, the last half of the Tribulation Period, just before Christ's 2nd Coming in Wrath and Judgment to restore all things. But in Christ's 1st Coming, He did not come in avengement to restore all things for National Israel but to suffer all things, therefore, according to the VRS He could not be the true Messiah. And if Jesus is not the true Messiah, then John's ministry to prepare the way for the Messiah could not be true either. With two swings of the blade, this counter-doctrine of the VRS tried to do away with the ministries of Jesus the Christ and of John the Baptist.
So, this is an extremely important question: Who is John the Baptist? Let's put together the pieces of the puzzle from the Gospel accounts. As mentioned earlier, John, when asked by the VRS if he was Elijah, he said definitively and straightforwardly NO (Jn. 1:21)! Let's say it again: John said he was not Elijah in fulfillment of Mal. 4:5.
But who does Jesus say he is? In Mark 9:11-13, the disciples, after coming down the mountain where they had just witnessed the transfiguration (where, by the way, they just saw Moses and ELIJAH! (Mk. 9:4-5)), some of the apostles asked Jesus about Elijah and his relationship to John the Baptist: Why do the scribes (the VRS) say that Elijah must come first? Jesus answered them: Indeed, Elijah comes first and restores all things. But Jesus goes on to explain that that was not what was happening at that time (His 1st Coming). All things were not now being restored. Rather The Son of Man that He must suffer many things, and be set at naught. According to Jesus' answer, Elijah is to be God's messenger just before the restoration of all things at Christ's 2nd Coming, which accords perfectly with Mal. 4:5-6. So, whoever John was, he was not the Elijah of Mal. 4:5 because John hadn't come before the Great and Terrible Day of the Lord when all things would be restored at Christ's 2nd Coming. He came before the suffering of all things by the Son of Man (the Lord Jesus Christ) when He would be regarded as nothing at His 1st Coming!
But then, Jesus, says something surprising: But I say unto you, that Elijah is indeed come, and they (the VRS) have done unto him whatsoever they wished (they put him in jail and will kill him) as it is written of him. So, which is it? Has Elijah come or hasn't he come? And what does this have to do with John and his ministry? To get another piece of the puzzle, we need to go to Mat. 17:10-13. Like Mark 9, this account is right after they witnessed the transfiguration on the mountain: Why do the scribes (the VRS) say that Elijah must come first? And Jesus answered: Elijah truly shall first come and restore all things, and that Elijah is come already, and they (the VRS) knew him not but have done unto him whatsoever they wished. Likewise shall also the Son of Man suffer of them (the VRS). So far, both accounts say the same things, and then Matthew gives us an additional detail: And the disciples understood that He spoke unto them of John the Baptist.
But we do still not have a completely clear answer with regard to our question: Has Elijah come, or hasn't he? And what does this have to do with John and his ministry? We find one more piece of the puzzle in Mat. 11:7-14. This time Jesus asks the multitudes about who they went out to see when they went out into the wilderness to see John. And at this time Jesus quotes Mal. 3:1, and He quotes it in reference to John the Baptist: Behold, I send My messenger before thy face, which shall prepare thy way before thee, unequivocally identifying John as that messenger who fulfills that prophecy. Jesus closes the discussion by saying: If you will receive it, this is Elijah, who is to come.
Based on these verses, the overall picture of John is beginning to be seen. Let's summarize. First of all, John himself says categorically that he is not the Elijah of Mal. 4:5 (Jn. 1:21). Jesus said that while Elijah is to come before the Great and Terrible Day of the Lord at Christ's 2nd Coming to restore all things in accord with Mal. 4:5, that is not what is happening at this time. At this time, Christ is suffering all things and will be regarded as nothing, and it is Elijah in the person of John the Baptist who comes before that in accord with Mal. 3:1.
So, how can this be? How does Elijah come in the person of John? To answer this question we need to put in place the final two pieces of the puzzle of who John is, and that will bring his ministry into full clarity. We find these pieces in Lk. 1:13-17 and Mat. 3:1-4. In Luke 1, the angel explains to Zacharias that his wife, Elizabeth, is pregnant, and that she will be giving birth to a son, whom he was to name John. The angel went on to say that through John's ministry, many of the children of Israel shall he turn to the Lord their God. Elijah will do the same thing in the future when Christ returns to restore all things. Finally, the angel explains that John shall go before Him in the SPIRIT and POWER of Elijah. We can add to this Matthew 3:1-4 where we read that John also comes in the appearance, in dress and diet, of Elijah, calling on the Nation of Israel to repent just as Elijah did in the past when he called on Israel to repent and leave Baal worship and return to the Lord (1 Kgs. 18).
So the answer to our question is that John is Elijah in the sense that he comes in the spirit and power of Elijah, doing many of the same things Elijah did in the past and will do again in the future at Christ's 2nd Coming. If anything, John is more like Elisha, the successor to Elijah, than to Elijah himself. Remember when Elijah was translated and removed from the earth, he left his mantle behind. Elisha took the mantle and received a double portion of Elijah's spirit and power (2 Kgs. 2:8-9). In fact, Elisha did two times the number of miracles that Elijah did. John is not Elijah anymore than Elisha was Elijah. He came in the spirit and the power of Elijah, calling the nation to repentance and to prepare the way for Christ at His 1st Coming as the Suffering Servant on behalf of His people the Israelites in accord with Is. 53.